Mastercraft Doors From Menards: Worth It? Reviews & Alternatives
Are Mastercraft doors from Menards truly a wise investment for your home, or are you better off exploring alternative options? Despite their energy efficiency and aesthetic appeal, a closer look reveals potential pitfalls that could significantly impact your satisfaction and wallet.
Mastercraft doors, a product of Midwest Manufacturing and distributed by Menards, present themselves as a viable option for homeowners seeking customized interior and exterior doors. The allure of energy efficiency, durability, and aesthetic appeal is undeniable. However, a deeper dive into the experiences of actual consumers paints a more nuanced picture, revealing potential drawbacks that warrant careful consideration before making a purchase.
The market offers a variety of door types, including steel, fiberglass, and wood, each with its unique set of advantages and disadvantages. Steel doors are often lauded for their security and affordability, while fiberglass doors mimic the appearance of wood without the maintenance. Wood doors, on the other hand, offer unparalleled aesthetic warmth but can be susceptible to warping and require more upkeep. Understanding the pros and cons of each material is crucial in selecting the optimal door for your home.
| Product Name | Mastercraft Doors |
| Manufacturer | Midwest Manufacturing |
| Distributor | Menards |
| Materials Offered | Steel, Fiberglass, Wood |
| Styles Offered | Customized interior and exterior doors in various styles |
| Key Features | Energy efficient, durable, and beautiful (depending on the material chosen) |
| Potential Drawbacks | Expensive, prone to warping, quality and customer service issues |
| Real Wood Jamb Cost (Approx.) | $199.00 to $234.00 per door |
| Reference Website | Menards Official Website |
The choice of jamb material, or the door frame, can significantly influence the overall cost. Mastercraft offers a real wood option, adding between $199.00 and $234.00 to the price of each door. This price point is consistent with other companies using real wood jambs, where costs can nearly double. The decision to opt for real wood jambs rests with the buyer, highlighting the importance of carefully evaluating budget considerations against aesthetic preferences.
Consumer reviews offer valuable insights into the real-world performance of Mastercraft doors. While some customers are satisfied with the product, a significant number have reported issues with quality, customer service, and the longevity of the doors. A concerning average rating of 1.8 based on 60 reviews raises red flags and underscores the need for thorough research before making a purchase. One recurring complaint involves the company's lack of support for issues such as broken mini blinds within the door's glass panes, indicating a potential lack of accountability.
One reviewer recounts a purchase in December 2009, where a small kink appeared in the mini blind inside the glass in March 2010. The inability to resolve the issue with either the manufacturer or Menards is a clear indication of the frustration buyers can experience with the after-sales service. This is not an isolated incident, as many users have reported similar customer service problems, which should factor heavily into the decision-making process.
The decision to purchase a Mastercraft door often comes down to balancing cost against desired features. For those seeking the look of real wood at a lower price point, Mastercraft might appear appealing. However, it's crucial to be mindful of potential drawbacks, such as the use of cheaper materials like pine or poplar in the casings of lower-priced doors. For exterior doors, steel, oak, or maple casings, coupled with higher-end hinges, are preferable for their durability and resistance to the elements.
The experience of installing the door is another critical factor. Some purchasers report that the door felt "cheap" and was not perfectly square, requiring considerable shimming and adjustment to achieve a proper fit. This can lead to wasted time and effort during installation, especially for those who prefer a smooth, hassle-free experience. In addition, some buyers find that the product is not adequately backed by the manufacturer, leaving them without a solution when issues arise.
However, some customers have found satisfaction with Mastercraft doors, citing that the doors are noticeably warmer than older ones, and the smooth opening and closing were a definite plus. When considering these factors, it's essential to carefully weigh the positive aspects against the negative to make an informed decision that aligns with your needs and expectations.
While the aesthetics of a Mastercraft door may initially capture the buyer's attention, there are other brands to consider. The Andersen 200 series sliding patio door, available at cost, offers a viable alternative that is comparable in price but potentially more reliable. The American Craftsman (now Andersen) sliding doors from Home Depot, which have performed without problems over the past 15 years, offer another choice for those looking for long-term durability. Additionally, Shwinco manufactures windows and doors that meet rigorous requirements, providing a reliable option for buyers who want a guarantee of quality.
The design and purchase of a customized door can be done from anywhere, but it requires careful consideration of your requirements and preferences. When assessing your options, consider the dimensions of your openings, the desired materials, and the styles that best fit your home's aesthetic. Remember that feng shui principles place importance on the placement of the stove, desk, and bed in a home, emphasizing the importance of every detail.
For those seeking pre-hung exterior door systems, the customer service issues reported in many reviews warrant serious consideration. If you decide to choose a Mastercraft door, it's essential to do your homework. Be sure to check the door and all the components to ensure that everything meets your expectations and that you are satisfied with the quality before committing to a purchase. In addition, familiarizing yourself with the installation process is crucial; it helps to avoid potential problems that could arise and helps you obtain the best outcome.
A good rule of thumb is to imagine your back to the hinge side of the door frame, standing in the middle of the door opening. This positioning helps to determine the "hand" and swing of the door. If the door opens toward your left, it is a left-hand door. If the door opens to the right, it is a right-hand door. Understanding these details ensures that you select the right door for your needs and avoid unnecessary complications during installation.
